Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tawfiq Al- Ghussein's avatar

Parliament has likely just voted for something that is not only morally indefensible, but potentially unlawful—something that may well be overturned in court. The decision to proscribe Palestine Action under anti-terror legislation represents one of the most blatant abuses of such laws in recent memory.

Despite the seriousness of this move, only 26 MPs voted against it. Disturbingly, many who are considered part of the Labour ‘left’ supported the proscription—including Momentum-backed MPs Navendu Mishra and Chris Webb—while others abstained entirely.

Among those who stood in opposition were:

• 9 Labour MPs: Diane Abbott, Tahir Ali, Richard Burgon, Ian Byrne, Imran Hussain, Kim Johnson, Clive Lewis, Grahame Morris, and Nadia Whittome.

• 3 suspended Labour MPs: Apsana Begum, John McDonnell, and Zarah Sultana.

• 3 Independent Alliance MPs: Shockat Adam, Jeremy Corbyn, and Adnan Hussain.

• 4 Green MPs: Sian Berry, Ellie Chowns, Carla Denyer, and Adrian Ramsay.

Some have claimed they couldn’t vote against the motion because of the inclusion of other groups, hastily bundled into the proscription order by Yvette Cooper. That’s no excuse. Like any parliamentary motion, if you object to any part of it, you vote against it.

This is a shameful moment for the Labour Party—a capitulation to tabloid-style, Trumpian politics at the expense of legal integrity and basic human rights. This isn’t about ideology. It’s about defending the rule of law and the right to dissent.

Expand full comment
Matt Szabo's avatar

Petition to support PA

https://palestinecampaign.eaction.org.uk/NoProscription

I queried the safety of signing this, although i have signed it. Will I be somehow incriminated for doing so? A friend informed me:

"The Govt Security Agencies monitor all extra parliamentary ( and much of Parliamentary ) opposition routinely. The Starmer led Labour Party HQ hired an IDF Intelligence Officer within weeks of gaining power. He is an expert at using IT to monitor Social Media. So my response to this is to do nothing , say nothing, that is illegal but proudly be open about resisting the erosion of hard-won liberties that we benefit from thanks to generations of good people taking direct action. You're already on the lists bud. But until the Bill is past signing [it] is not illegal. Regarding the murderous IDF there is no legal right for an Occupying force to claim self-defence and there is a legally sanctioned obligation for an occupied population to use force against the invading military. But of course all of that will be familiar to you and your parents. All the best."

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts